Senior Design: A Fine Powder Transport System

Group Project for MEEG304 at the University of Delaware, Sponsored by QFix

An image of an industrial flexible screw conveyor

Background and Problem Statement

QFix is a medical device company located in Avondale, PA. They focus on the design and manufacture of patient positioning systems, used to keep patients comfortable and still during radiation therapy procedures. One type of product they make is a thermoplastic mask, which is form-fitted to the patient's head.

An image of a patient wearing a thermoplastic mask.
Patient positioning mask made by QFix.

The thermoplastic masks are created from a combination of polymers, including a unique additive "yellow powder" (which was not named or specified to keep QFix's IP protected). This yellow powder must be introduced to the mixing system through a hopper located 9 feet above the manufacturing floor. Before the project, the hopper was refilled manually - every 15 minutes, an employee will climb up a ladder with a drum of powder and a hand scoop, and top off the hopper. QFix was looking for a solution where they could empty an entire 25kg drum of yellow powder at once, and keep the hopper full automatically. Additionally, having the loading process closer to the manufacturing floor would be safer and easier.

Constraints and Targets

Constraint Target Value
Powder availabile in hopper ≥ 72g at all times
Ergonomics & Safety Adhere to OSHA 1910.212 and
NIOSH lifting recommendation of < 51lb
Device Size Max footprint: 123" x 78"
Reach: 8'8" above floor
System compatibility System must be able to be retrofitted to existing machinery
System must accommodate 25kg powder drum
Cost < $15,000 for automated powder transport system
< $1,500 for subcomponents.

Wants and Targets

Want Target Value
Powder utilization < 1% of each drum (250g) lost to spillage / dead volume
Mobility & Ease of Use Only 1 employee required to operate the loading system

Substitute Powder

As stated earlier, QFix was understandably protective of their yellow powder additive, for IP security. For our testing, we were tasked with finding a suitable proxy material, which had similar properties to the additive powder. QFix provided us with the relevant properties of the powder, and this table summarizes our options when looking at alternatives.

Material Density (g/ML) Bulk Density (g/ML) Particle Diameter (μm)
QFix "Yellow Powder" 0.8 0.4-0.5 100-150
Polystyrene Microspheres 1.07 N/A 100
Powdered Detergent >1 1.32-1.49 80-250
Whey Protein Powder <1 0.41-0.61 100-150

After doing the research, we found that Whey Protein Powder was the most suitable proxy material to use for our testing. This also had the added benefit of being readily available and relatively inexpensive. We were able to quickly purchase 25kg of protein powder for $100.


Selected Solution

Overview

After researching existing solutions to the problem, our team decided on using an industrially available flexible screw conveyor. These systems are common particularly in the food processing industry, are designed and built to industrial quality, and have already been validated. In order to more easily move the yellow powder drums around, and empty them into the base of the screw conveyor, we would design a pail handler / palletizer, which would be built by us in house.

A sketch of our proposed solution
Sketched overview of our proposed solution.

Flexible Screw Conveyor

Early on, it was clear that designing and building an industrial-quality screw conveyor ourselves was out of the question. Instead, we focused on working with manufacturers such as Flexicon and Hapman, seeing which of their products may work for our sponsors. We contacted sales agents at each of these companies, and provided them with the available dimensions and powder properties as measured by QFix. Hapman's quoted system was both less expensive and better suited to QFix's needs, so this is what we recommended to our project sponsors. Hapman's solution consisted of 3 parts:

The total cost of the screw conveyor system from Hapman came in at $20,037. While this was over the initial budget, the increase in cost was necessary to meet the desired metrics.

A hapman screw conveyor
Example Hapman Screw Conveyor.

Pail Handler and Lid Adapter

In order to safely move and invert the yellow powder drums, our team designed and built a rolling pail handler. The pail handler was constructed from an aluminum 8020 t-slot extrusion frame. A steel cradle for the drum was welded together. The cradle had buckled straps that locked the drum in place by its built-in handles for inversion, as well as a ratchet strap that would secure the drum laterally. The cradle moved up and down on a steel linear rail, and a winch provided 7:1 mechanical advantage. The cradle was able to sit flat on the floor, meaning the yellow powder drum did not need to be lifted by hand to be loaded. Rubber stoppers prevent the drum from being inverted past 180°.

In order to have the yellow powder flow out of the drum and into the base of the flexible screw conveyor without spillage, our team built a lid adapter. This was a funnel with a knife gate, and mated with the drum's threaded mouth. The funnel allowed for more accurate dispensing of the powder, and helped prevent powder from clouding up and drifting away. The knife gate allowed the drum to be inverted wherever convenient, then moved into position and emptied.

A rendered image of an aluminum pail handler
CAD Render of the Pail Handler.
A rendered image of a plastic funnel with a knife gate
CAD Render of the Lid Adapter.

Constraint and Want Validation

Constraint Target Value Measured Value Pass/Fail
Powder availabile in hopper ≥ 72g at all times ≥ 72g, specified by Hapman Pass
Ergonomics & Safety Adhere to OSHA 1910.212 and
NIOSH lifting recommendation of < 51lb
Met OSHA 1910.212
Max lifting force 8lb
Pass
Device Size Max footprint: 123" x 78"
Reach: 8'8" above floor
Hapman agreed to footprint and reach specifications Pass
System compatibility System must be able to be retrofitted to existing machinery
System must accommodate 25kg powder drum
No modifications to QFix facility required Pass
Cost < $15,000 for automated powder transport system
< $1,500 for subcomponents.
$20,037 for screw conveyor
$1,000 for pail handler
Fail
Want Target Value Measured Value Pass/Fail
Powder utilization < 1% of each drum (250g) lost to spillage / dead volume < 100g lost per drum Pass
Mobility & Ease of Use Only 1 employee required to operate the loading system Both pail handler and screw conveyor can be moved by 1 person Pass

Video Demonstration